
Florian, Douglas. 2007. Comets, Stars, the Moon, and Mars. New York: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt
Publishing Company. ISBN: 978-0-15-205372-7.
Book
Review:
Douglas Florian adds to his impressive collection of
children’s books with the poetry collection included in Comets, Stars, the Moon, and Mars, a Kirkus Best Book of the Year
and Horn Book Fanfare List selection.
With its heavenly artwork, rhythmic rhymes and informational text,
Florian straddles the line nicely between a poetry and informational book. Access features include a table of contents a
“galactic” glossary and a selected bibliography giving accuracy to the
scientific information provided in the poems.
Using a combination of gouache, collage, cut-outs
and rubber stamps on brown paper, Florian lavishly illustrates each of the 20
poems in the book primarily in the colors of outer space: deep blue, bright
orange and starry yellow. Beginning with the universe, galaxy, solar system and
each planet and continuing with comets, constellations and black holes, each
of the poems contains devices of sound, such as rhyme and alliteration, which
create a pleasant reading experience.
Most of the poems rhyme in the aa/bb/cc pattern, such as in “Skywatch” – “On a clear night you might try/To gaze upon the starry sky”), with some other patterns for contrast, such as in “Venus” - “Scalding-hot surfaces,/Nine hundred degrees./Nothing can live there,/No creatures,/No trees.” Keeping the tone light, but covering actual facts about the topics, the author has created a poetry collection which will appeal to a variety of ages.
Most of the poems rhyme in the aa/bb/cc pattern, such as in “Skywatch” – “On a clear night you might try/To gaze upon the starry sky”), with some other patterns for contrast, such as in “Venus” - “Scalding-hot surfaces,/Nine hundred degrees./Nothing can live there,/No creatures,/No trees.” Keeping the tone light, but covering actual facts about the topics, the author has created a poetry collection which will appeal to a variety of ages.
Florian also playfully places his text on some of the
pages as a surprise, such as “The universe is every place/including all the e m
p t y space;” or the poem for “a galaxy”
written in a galactic spiral. The combination of the illuminating illustrations
and the rhythmic repetition of the poems culminates in a sure winner for the
author and a visual feast for the reader.
Sharing
the Poetry:
Florian’s space collection could be used in a number
of different ways, including a story time about the planets or moon, with an accompanying
craft, or in a science unit in a classroom.
Combined with other age-appropriate books on the topics, the poems could
be peppered into the instruction time as a fun change of pace.
Selected
Poem:
In a story time based on the moon, a children’s
librarian could read other short non-fiction books about the topic, along with
Florian’s poem “The Moon,” and have the children carve the filling of Oreo
Cookies into the shapes of the phases of the moon:

The Moon
A new moon
isn’t really new,
It’s merely somewhat dark to view.
A crescent
moon may seem to smile,
Gladly back after a while.
A half
moon is half dark, half light,
At sunset look due south to sight.
A full
moon is a sight to see,
Circular in geometry.
After full, the moon will wane
Night by night, then start again.
References:
Books in Print. n.d. Comets, Stars, the Moon, and Mars. http://ezproxy.twu.edu:2125/DetailedView.aspx?hreciid=|24083537|13649214&mc=USA#
(accessed February 11, 2014).
Douglas Florian Author Visits. 2012. .http://douglasflorianauthorvisits.blogspot.com/
(accessed February 11, 2014).
Science Bob's Blog. 2011. "Oreo Cookie Moon Phases." http://www.sciencebob.com/blog/?p=828 (accessed February 18, 2014).
Science Bob's Blog. 2011. "Oreo Cookie Moon Phases." http://www.sciencebob.com/blog/?p=828 (accessed February 18, 2014).
No comments:
Post a Comment